How Do You Cut a Nine-Inch-Tall Apple Pie? A Thanksgiving Field Manual

Photo: Skyler Ewing / Pexels

How Do You Cut a Nine-Inch-Tall Apple Pie? A Thanksgiving Field Manual

· 6 min read · By Greg Duffie

Most apple pies are a pie. This one is a geological event.

The Blue Owl Restaurant & Bakery in Kimmswick, Missouri, makes something called the Levee High Apple Pie. By most accounts it stands about nine inches tall, packs 18 hand-peeled apples, and weighs roughly ten pounds. That is the weight of a Thanksgiving turkey. That is the weight of a bowling ball. Your grandmother's pie plate has never been asked to do anything like this, and frankly it would like to speak to a lawyer.

And because America is a great nation, there is a caramel pecan version, where the whole mountain gets shellacked in a thick coat of caramel and pecans. According to Missouri Life, the topping is meant to mimic the dirt and rocks that shore up a levee. We are not making that up. It is a pie with an engineering backstory.

A Pie Built Out of a Flood

The pie dates to the Great Flood of 1993, when the Mississippi rose so high it licked the Blue Owl's deck and volunteers sandbagged a levee to save the town. Owner Mary Hostetter honored them the only way a Midwestern baker knows how: by building a dessert with the structural profile of the levee itself.

Other towns put up a plaque. Kimmswick put up a ten-pound pie. We know which approach we respect more.

Since then it's been on Food Network, landed on Oprah's Favorite Things, and prompted The Takeout to run a headline that simply read: “We Must Destroy The Tall Pie Before It Destroys Us.” One person online compared it to the turkey in Christmas Vacation. Another suggested we “kill it with fire.” Those are the two correct reactions, and we feel both of them at once.

It Arrives Frozen, on Dry Ice, Like a Specimen

You can't just pop down to Kimmswick (well, you can — Tuesday through Sunday, 10 to 3), so most people order it through Goldbelly, which ships it nationwide, frozen and unbaked, packed in dry ice. The listing includes the warning “do not remove dry ice with bare hands,” which is the first time a dessert has ever come with a hazmat advisory.

You then bake it yourself. The short version of the instructions:

  1. Preheat to 375°F.
  2. Brush the frozen top with an egg wash and sprinkle on sugar.
  3. Put a baking sheet or drip pan under it. This is not a suggestion. This is the pie telling you, politely, what it is capable of.
  4. Bake 60 to 75 minutes, until the crust is golden and the apples yield to a toothpick.
  5. Cool, then microwave the caramel-pecan topping and spread it over the summit.

The listing says it serves 10 to 12 people. It has clearly never met your family.

So How Do You Actually Cut This Thing?

Here's what nobody tells you: there are no official cutting instructions. The directions end at “slice and serve,” as if that were one step and not a multi-agency operation. So we've drafted a protocol.

Step 1: Let It Rest. Seriously.

Eighteen apples' worth of molten filling needs time to set, or your first cut becomes a landslide. Give it at least an hour. Use that hour to clear the table, alert the neighbors, and file a flight plan.

Step 2: Choose Your Weapon

A standard pie server is useless here — it's like bringing a spoon to a mining operation. You want a long serrated bread knife, at least 10 inches, so the blade clears the whole height in one pass. Run it under hot water and wipe it dry between cuts so the caramel doesn't glue it shut.

Step 3: Saw, Don't Press

Pressing straight down on a nine-inch structure is how you get a pie that explodes outward like a pressed sandwich. Use gentle sawing strokes through the caramel shell first, then glide down through the apples. Let the knife do the work. You are a surgeon, not a lumberjack.

Step 4: Cut Fewer, Smaller Wedges Than You Think

A normal “eighth of a pie” here is roughly the size of a hardcover book. Twelve thin wedges is the move. If someone asks for “just a sliver,” give them a sliver. It will still be the biggest thing on their plate, including the turkey.

Step 5: Extract With Two Tools

One spatula under the slice, one hand (or a second spatula) bracing the tall side. Tip it onto its side on the plate — it's more stable lying down, and honestly so are you after Thanksgiving dinner.

Step 6: The Horizontal Option

For the brave: cut the whole pie in half horizontally, like a layer cake, and serve the top tier and bottom tier separately. Purists will object. Purists are not the ones holding a ten-pound pie over a tablecloth.

A Brief Thanksgiving Risk Assessment

  • Turkey: 15 pounds, takes four hours, may give someone food poisoning.
  • Levee High Pie: 10 pounds, takes 75 minutes, will absolutely give someone a personality.
  • Your Uncle Dave: Will try to eat it with a fork straight from the pan. Let him. It's a holiday.

One more thing: the pie keeps one to two months in the freezer before baking and up to four days in the fridge after. So yes, you can technically buy one now and save it for Christmas. We don't believe you will.

The Verdict

Is it practical? No. Is it reasonable? Absolutely not. Is it an apple pie built to honor flood volunteers, crowned in caramel “rocks,” tall enough to need its own cutting strategy? Yes, and that's exactly why it belongs on your table.

Reviewers who've eaten it in person keep saying the same things: phenomenal, get the caramel pecan, get it with ice cream, and plan to take half your slice home. That last part isn't a complaint. It's a warning.

You can order the Levee High Caramel Pecan Apple Pie on Goldbelly. Bring a bread knife. Bring a drip pan. Bring witnesses.

GD

Greg Duffie · Editor

Greg Duffie runs 37SOLUTIONS, a managed hosting and IT services company, and runs this site, where he applies the same rigor to deep-fried cheese that he applies to production infrastructure. Every article involves food that was actually eaten by a real person who was fully aware of what he was doing.

Keep Going (You Have Time)

Conventional Fried Foods vs. Air-Fried Foods
food

Conventional Fried Foods vs. Air-Fried Foods

Are you torn between the crispy indulgence of conventional fried foods and the supposed health benefits of air-fried options? Discover the differences to make an informed choice!

February 19, 2025·4 min read